top of page
Search

Five Vignettes from Who Killed JFK?

Writer: Fred Litwin
Fred Litwin
11 minutes ago
8 min read

Here are five vignettes from the New Reiner/Russell/Hoffman book, Who Killed JFK?


  1. The book accepts Jack Martin as a credible source of information: (pages 138 - 139 of the Kindle edition)

Jack Martin, who was Banister’s lead investigator, told the HSCA that he had seen Oswald and Banister in the office and that David Ferrie was there as well. According to Martin, “In the late Summer of 1963, I was sitting in the office of Guy Banister… David Ferrie walked in wearing an army-type fatigue suit and sun glasses. Also with him were three or four young men in their twenties, dressed in sport shirts. One of them was Morris Brownlee. Another was a man they referred to as ‘Lee.’ After the assassination, I recognized Lee Harvey Oswald as one of the men who had walked in with Ferrie and Brownlee. All of them went in to see Banister and the door was then shut so I wouldn’t know what they talked about.”

Here is the Martin affidavit:

 

Jack Martin never said anything in 1963 or 1964 about seeing Oswald with Ferrie.



Jim Garrison: Who else was there besides Oswald?


Jack Martin: Oh, Ferrie and a bunch of kids come in.


Jim Garrison: Oswald and Ferrie?


Jack Martin: Ferrie and a bunch of young fellows come in. And Ferrie had one of these officer with xxx on, like they wear in Vietnam, you know. And he had a pair of aviator glasses and mohair sticking down. I thought he was one of the Cubans. In fact, Arcacha was with him with a … the Cuban front.


Jim Garrison: You mean that the anti-Castro type were there.


Jack Martin: Yeah, yeah. That’s a good point.


Jim Garrison: … and how old were they?


Jack Martin: They range anywhere from 17 to 21, maybe, something like that.


Jim Garrison: And where was Oswald?


Jack Martin: Well, he was with his friend, because one of the guys, he says this well, he’s a friend of mine. Well, I was sitting there, and I don’t think anybody was in the office. Miss Roberts, she wasn’t even working there.


Jim Garrison: Roughly, what was ...


Jack Martin: Oswald was in talking to some people, and these guys came in to see Banister.


Jim Garrison: Roughly, how many people with Ferrie?


Jack Martin: I’d say three or four. Including Arcacha and this guy Oswald with Ferrie. And there were a couple of other guys.


Of course, Sergio Arcacha Smith was not in New Orleans in 1963.


Jack Martin was a serial liar, and no one took him seriously; including the HSCA:



  1. Who Killed JFK also believed that Lee Harvey Oswald was Clairvoyant: (page 143 in the Kindle edition.

On August 1, 1963, Oswald mailed a letter to Vincent T. Lee, the head of the FPCC in New York. It was a progress report of sorts, with Oswald’s customary spelling errors. “Through the efforts of some exial ‘gusanos’ [a derogatory term for opponents of the Castro government], a street demonstration was attacked and we were officially cautioned by police,” Oswald wrote. “This incident robbed me of what support I had[,] leaving me alone. Nevertheless thousands of circulars were disturbed and many, many pamphlets which your office supplied.”
The altercation didn’t actually happen until August 9. Somehow he knew exactly what was going to occur and wanted to make sure the leadership of FPCC did too.

Oswald was not clairvoyant and he did not know "exactly what was going to occur." He was describing an earlier altercation.




  1. Who Killed JFK? believes Tosh Plumlee's story about Lee Harvey Oswald: (page 94 in the Kindle edition)

Robert “Tosh” Plumlee, an Army veteran who later claimed to have flown CIA cover missions as a pilot, claimed that Lee Harvey Oswald spent time in 1959 at a secret intelligence and military installation in the outskirts of Raleigh, North Carolina. Plumlee said it was there that he crossed paths with the nineteen-year-old Oswald. Interviewed for the Who Killed JFK? podcast, Plumlee reported that he was “under the impression that Lee was being trained for a specific operation… This kid my age was part of the original recruitment of teenagers who were getting in trouble.”

This is just not true.



Who Killed JFK? tries to support the allegation with this paragraph: (page 240 in the Kindle edition)

There was reportedly an Office of Naval Intelligence operation in Nags Head, North Carolina. As a Marine, Oswald was said to have briefly trained in Nags Head, and, as reported by the Washington Post, the CIA planned to use a remote resort hotel in Nags Head in 1961 as a “safe haven” for Cuban defectors and Cuban refugees from the Bay of Pigs invasion. It was clearly a site used for clandestine operations.

There was no such operation in Nags Head. And yes, according to convicted spy Edwin G. Moore, the CIA planned to use a hotel in 1961, but the property burnt down. Moore was convicted of espionage in 1977, and was sentenced to life in prison. He was also accused of burning down his own hotel but was acquitted.


  1. Who Killed JFK? Believes Plumlee's story about flying Roselli and E. Howard Hunt to Dallas on November 22, 1963: (pages 202 - 203 in the Kindle edition)

Johnny Roselli was the Mob’s “man in Hollywood” and a veteran of CIA–Mafia plots against Castro. Tosh Plumlee, a CIA contract pilot who had formerly been stationed with Oswald at Nags Head, North Carolina, told the Who Killed JFK? podcast that on the morning of November 22, 1963, Roselli was on the small plane he copiloted from Tampa to New Orleans to Dallas.
E. Howard Hunt, CIA covert operations specialist and future Watergate operative, was also on the plane, according to Plumlee. Hunt’s son St. John told the Who Killed JFK? podcast that he remembered asking his mother where his father was that day: “She said, ‘He’s in Dallas on business.’ Later, my father told me he was a bench warmer—he knew who was involved, the escape routes, the safe houses. He had the whole mission in his head.”

I've written several blog posts about Plumlee:


A review of Plumlee's new book.


Plumlee claims to have met Oswald on several occasions.


Plumlee's new book is quite the novel.


Part One of two parts.


Second of two parts.


Some of Plumlee's interesting activities in 1959.


A bizarre story in which Plumlee writes to the FBI that he has provided bad information to an article about him in a Denver magazine.


Plumlee steals a plane and writes some bad checks.


Did Plumlee fly an abort team to Dallas or the actual assassins?


Plumlee writes to Palamara that Dinkin's messages might have been the intelligence to send the abort team to Dallas.


PBS Frontline investigated Plumlee's allegations about Nags Head, North Carolina and could not corroborate any part of his story.


Wow, Tosh finds someone who has a photograph of Jack Ruby, Johnny Roselli, Sam Giancana, Ed McLamore, and Lee Harvey Oswald.




  1. The Backyard Photographs are back:


Just when you thought that it had been proven that the backyard photographs of Lee Harvey Oswald with his rifle and pistol are legitimate, along comes this new book with a new objection.


They present Marina Oswald's testimony to the HSCA in which she talks about taking the photographs: (page 129 in the Kindle edition)


M.O.: I do believe it was a weekend and he asked me to take a picture of him and I refused because I don’t know how to take pictures. That is the only pictures I ever took in my whole life. So we argued over it and I thought the pose, or whatever he was wearing was just horrible, but he insisted that I just click, just push the button and I believe I did it twice and that was it…


Q.: And you recall testifying about these same two photographs when you testified to the Warren Commission?


M.O.: Yes; I remember them asking if I ever took the pictures and I had completely forgotten because it was only once in my life and I didn’t know how to take pictures. Yes, when they showed me that, yes, I did take the pictures…


Q.: What did he tell you to do with the camera as far as taking the pictures?


M.O.: He just told me which button to push and I did.


Q.: Did you hold it up to your eye and look through the viewer to take the picture?


M.O.: Yes…


Their objection is that this is not how Oswald's camera worked: (pages 129 - 130 in the Kindle edition)

That is not how one uses an Imperial Reflex camera, which has a very unique operating style. The person taking the photo holds the camera by their belly button and looks down through the viewfinder, not toward the subject. Then the photographer presses down on a small lever. If Marina took this photo—and, as she claimed, it was the only photo she ever took—it seems she would recall more accurately the unique way she operated the Imperial Reflex camera.

Really? She said she took the photographs. So what if she presses a small lever instead of a button?


To the authors of Who Killed JFK? this could also mean that perhaps Marina did not take the photographs: (page 130 in the Kindle edition)

Another scenario is that the photos might be real, but Marina might not have been the one who took them. And if that is the case, who took the photos and why?

Is it necessary to add mystery to the photographs?


This is just a start -- there are many more factoids to come.



Previous Relevant Blog Posts on the Reiner/Russell podcast/book, Who Killed JFK?


In the podcast series, he was the tactician of the JFK assassination. That has disappeared in the book.


There is just one thing missing from Who Killed JFK? -- and that is evidence.


Here is the proof that he died of a heart attack.


An outrageous claim without any evidence.


The introduction is cause for concern.


A few thoughts about this book.


There is no evidence tying Willoughby to the assassination.


How on earth could Rob Reiner and his partners believe this ridiculous story?


We take apart the second five episodes of Reiner's podcast on the JFK assassination.


We take apart the first five episodes of Reiner's podcast on the JFK assassination.


Was there a fake defector program at Nags Head, North Carolina?


Flimsy evidence is cited that originated in Hustler Magazine.


Reiner believes the two-Oswald theory.


This blog post also covers the concluding episode of Reiner's podcast.


Conspiracy theorists have no regard for truth.







Post: Blog2_Post

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

©2020 by On The Trail of Delusion. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page