top of page
Search

Rob Reiner's Plot - Where's the Beef?

Writer: Fred Litwin
Fred Litwin
5 minutes ago
12 min read

The new Reiner/Russell/Hoffman book, Who Killed JFK?, is finally out and I have been reading my Kindle copy since I woke up.


It is incredibly underwhelming. The footnoting is sparse and the book contains many conspiracy factoids -- like the Mauser, mysterious death the supposed plot in Chicago, the Richard Case Nagell story, forgery of the autopsy photographs, the location of the Kennedy's neck/back wound, Oswald's false defection, Tosh Plumlee, etc. They even believe that the cartridge cases, found near the sixth-floor window at the Texas School Book Depository were planted.


It's a conspiracy dream!


I will certainly write blog posts on all of the above, but right now I want to focus on their big picture.


Chapter 61 is "Architecture of the Assassination." (Page 273 of the Kindle edition)

The evidence of an existing execution pipeline—CIA officers to Mob intermediaries to assassins—is documented. While at the time of this writing, there is no declassified order that directly ties the CIA’s ZR/RIFLE or Operation Northwoods to the JFK assassination, the operational capability and the relationships that would be indispensable to a domestic assassination were active in 1963. As mentioned in chapters 41 and 42, the combination of a ZR/RIFLE plan within an Operation Northwoods framework is consistent with a design to pin the assassination on a pro-Castro patsy in order to initiate a response aimed at Cuba.
So, if we allow that these plans could have been turned toward JFK by men with motive, the next step is decoding the operational engineering of such an event.

Nice sleight of hand here. The plots against Castro are "consistent with a design to pin the assassination on a pro-Castro patsy in order to initiate a response aimed at Cuba."


Note the inclusion of Project Northwoods into the paragraph. There is a complete chapter in the book about Northwoods and they treat it as something that had nothing to do with the JFK administration. (page 194 in the Kindle edition)

Kennedy outright rejected Operation Northwoods. In fact, shortly after hearing the proposal in March 1962, Kennedy declined to reappoint General Lemnitzer to his role as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, effectively removing him. This was just another sign to many in the military/intelligence apparatus that President Kennedy had grown increasingly accommodating to the Communists.

But the Northwoods plan was all part of Operation Mongoose in which JFK asked all elements of the U.S. government to come up with plans to target Cuba. Yes, he rejected Northwoods, but the plan was updated by his friend Maxwell Taylor one year later. Does anybody really believe that Taylor was also plotting against JFK?


Northwoods didn't pop out of thin air -- it was part of Operation Mongoose.


Northwoods wasn't a rogue operation.


I find the text of the redactions he complains about.


Russell then tells us about a new conspiracy: (page 275 in the Kindle edition)

More than three decades after the assassination, retired CIA officer Robert Crowley described intelligence counternarrative techniques in a tape-recorded phone conversation with researcher Gregory Douglas. “You see, we set up a disinformation group to spread confusion and to distract anyone from digging too deeply,” he said in one interview with Douglas. In another, he said, “The Kennedy business has the myth makers working overtime. Have you read any of the fantasy books? Men with umbrellas? People hidden in the sewers? Hoover shooting at him from some bank building? The Hunt brothers potting away from a black helicopter? Well, we’re responsible for a lot of that. Feed silly rumors to the babblers in the nut fringe and they stir up so much mud, you can’t see the truth.”

Here is a link to the supposed interviews with Crowley. I don't know how legit these interviews were, but you can easily see there is a lot of nonsense there.


So, all the nonsense we have been reading in conspiracy books was actually a CIA plot?


Reiner/Russell/Hoffman then go into the institutional enablers of the assassination: Allen Dulles, James Angleton, and H. L. Hunt,


Nice to know but is there any evidence?


Here is what they say about Dulles: (pages 276 - 277 in the Kindle edition)

Dulles’s biographer David Talbot didn’t mince words about the former CIA director’s role in the assassination: “Over the final months of JFK’s presidency, a clear consensus took shape within America’s deep state: Kennedy was a national security threat. For the good of the country, he must be removed. And Dulles was the only man with the stature, connections, and decisive will to make something of this enormity happen. He had already assembled a killing machine to operate overseas. Now he prepared to bring it home to Dallas.”

Talbot may not have minced words, but where is the evidence for any of this? Where is the evidence that a clear consensus that Kennedy must be removed within the "deep state"?


And James Angleton? (page 277 in the Kindle edition)

Angleton also controlled Oswald’s file. As author and ex–military intelligence operative John Newman has reported, Angleton’s fingerprints were all over Oswald. He secretly monitored Oswald as early as 1959, and his team opened a file on him in 1960. The file was open during the days leading up to the assassination. This information was tightly controlled, including the decision not to alert anyone to someone claiming to be Oswald visiting the Soviet and Cuban embassies in Mexico in the weeks prior to Dallas.

Angleton didn't control Oswald's file. Yes, a file was opened on Oswald when he defected. So what? Someone claiming to be Oswald?


The last institutional enabler of the assassination is H. L. Hunt: (page 278 in the Kindle edition)

The role Hunt played in building a hostile climate for Kennedy in Dallas is undeniable. His grip over the city, from his media assets to his relationships with politicians and police officers, made him the most influential man in the state of Texas. A 1975 FBI document repeated a report by journalist Earl Golz that Hunt was reportedly aware of potential violence along JFK’s motorcade route and left the door open that additional revelations might emerge that could implicate the billionaire.

So, the information was reported to the police and the FBI? So, what exactly is the issue?



Who Killed JFK then lists the planners of the assassination: Bill Harvey, David Atlee Phillips, Santo Trafficante, Johnny Roselli, David Morales, and Carlos Marcello: (page 278 in the Kindle edition)

For some, it was business; for others, it was personal; and for most, it was both. It is well-documented that these men were working together to build a team that could plan and execute assassinations. They had money, experience, and a network of assassins ready to act.

Yes, a few of them were working to assassinate Castro at the behest of John and Robert Kennedy.


But what evidence is there that any of these people planned the assassination of JFK?


For instance, here is what they say about Bill Harvey: (page 279 in the Kindle edition)

To this day, despite the recent trove of released documents, the CIA is still withholding significant material on Bill Harvey, including his whereabouts on November 22, 1963.

We know exactly where Harvey was on November 22, 1963. He was in Sardinia.


Here is an excerpt from Gus Russo's excellent book, Live by the Sword: The Secret War Against Castro and the Death of JFK: (page 304)

Sardinia, Italy
Bill Harvey, the CIA’s former Mongoose coordinator, was unconscious. His drinking had progressed from habit to disease after his exile to Italy a year earlier. When the telex noting Kennedy’s murder was received by his deputy, Harvey had to be awakened from a late-day martini stupor. The man who hated the Kennedys, both for their treatment of him and for their naive directives regarding Cuba, staggered to his feet.
What he said to his deputy should be taken with Harvey’s condition in mind, and the fact that there is only one witness to his comments, but that witness was so stunned that he wrote it down for posterity. “This was bound to happen,” blustered Harvey, “and it’s probably good that it did.” Soon, when Harvey discovered that his deputy was spending time helping local officials with condolences, he sent the deputy packing for the U.S. “I haven’t got time for this kind of crap,” Harvey told him.

Previous Relevant Blog Posts on William Harvey


We find the Charles Niles who worked in aviation.


There really is no mystery about Harvey's FAA Credentials.


Removing redactions in Harvey's Church Committee testimony do not shed light on the Fair Play for Cuba Committee.


A rebuttal to Morley's response to my post Was Bill Harvey in Dallas in November of 1963?


There is no credible evidence Harvey was in Dallas in November of 1963.


Yes, Jefferson Morley and Anna Paulina Luna are after the travel records of Bill Harvey for 1963 because believe he might have been seen on a flight to Dallas in November. But there is very little evidence for this.


The discussion of Santos Trafficante had this little gem: (page 280 in the Kindle edition)

Castro intelligence operative Fabian Escalante believed that two of the shooters were members of Trafficante’s “Havana crew.” Colonel William Bishop corroborated this claim, telling Dick Russell: “Trafficante, that’s where the money came from for the expenses to set up this assassination.”

Escalante is mentioned eighteen times in the book. But why on earth should we believe Fabian Escalante? He had been the head of the Cuban Department of State Security (DSE) and was later a senior official in the Cuban Interior Ministry. He had a vested interest in blaming the CIA and anti-Castro Cubans for the JFK assassination.


You can read a lot of the nonsense that Escalante wrote about the JFK assassination in this blog post:





David Morales is accused of being involved in both the RFK and the JFK assassination: (page 282 in the Kindle edition)

Several other individuals who knew Morales later alleged that he was involved in the Kennedy assassination, including two who reported Morales’s own incriminating remarks. Robert “Bob” Walton and Ruben Carbajal, longtime friends of Morales, recounted a conversation with him in a hotel room in 1973. Gaeton Fonzi, the investigator for the House Select Committee on Assassinations, reported that Morales launched into an angry tirade about President Kennedy, telling them: “I was in Dallas when we got the son of a bitch, and I was in Los Angeles when we got the little bastard”—a reference to the assassination of Robert Kennedy five years later. Carbajal recalled Morales tying his rage directly to the Bay of Pigs, saying that JFK had been responsible for forcing him to watch the men he recruited and trained be wiped out. “Well,” Morales reportedly concluded, “we took care of that son of a bitch, didn’t we?”

The quote "we took care of that son of a bitch" comes from an interview with Robert Walton who was an attorney for Morales. It was his recollection from an evening in which a lot of alcohol was drunk:

From a Gaeton Fonzi file.
From a Gaeton Fonzi file.
Morales was a legendary figure in CIA covert operations. According to close associate Tom Clines, if you saw Morales walking down the street in a Latin American capital, you knew a coup was about to happen. When the subject of the Kennedys came up in a late-night session with friends in 1973, Morales launched into a tirade that finished: "I was in Dallas when we got the son of a bitch and I was in Los Angeles when we got the little bastard." From this line grew my odyssey into the spook world of the 60s and the secrets behind the death of Bobby Kennedy.

The quote about being in Dallas and in LA originated in a 1995 interview between conspiracy author Noel Twyman and Robert Walton, attorney for Morales:

So, he can't "specifically remember he said he was in Dallas."


Reiner/Russell/Hoffman bring up Carlos Marcello's "confession": (page 283 in the Kindle edition)

Eventually the law caught up with Marcello. In 1985, he was in a federal facility in Texarkana, Texas. An FBI document reveals that Jack Van Laningham, who the document refers to as a reliable informant, was in the same prison as Marcello. Van Laningham reported a conversation he had with Marcello about the Kennedy assassination: “Carlos Marcello discussed his intense dislike of former President John Kennedy as he often did. Unlike other such tirades against Kennedy, however, on this occasion, Carlos Marcello said, referring to President Kennedy, ‘Yeah, I had the son of a bitch killed. I’m glad I did it. I’m sorry I couldn’t have done it myself.’ ”

We don't actually have a tape of Marcello saying any of this. All we have is Laningham's word. And here is what he said in another video:


Narrator: In the long months ahead, while Jack Van Laningham waits for the FBI to free him, he maintains that Marcello tells him more about the assassination.


Laningham: He told me that the shooter was his boy and had him down to his farm in New Orleans numerous times. I said, "Who are you talking about, Carl?" He says, "You know who I'm talking about. The guy, they claim, shot Kennedy from the book depository." He says, "The guy was my man. I had him in my pocket. I had him in my pocket. He did what the hell I told him to do and he said, we figured the cops was gonna blow him away when they saw him up in the Depository. But they didn't. [that. Some take] Ruby is his man in Texas, running his organization there, he's skimming off of Marcello. He owes them. He owes them big. He could have had him killed, but he didn't. He kept him in his pocket for what he was planning.


So, Oswald was Marcello's man? Is that what Reiner/Russell/Hoffman believe?


Now, it's time for "ground operatives." (pag 284 in the Kindle edition)

It’s worth repeating that while there is no definitive proof of any of the following shooters, there is substantial circumstantial evidence that leads us to believe that these individuals might have been involved. These men have a documented presence in or near Dealey Plaza on November 22, a documented operational linkage, and attribution by a named source.

"No definitive proof," and "might have been involved."


Reiner/Russell/Hoffman sayd that "there were three or four shooters, with as many as six shots fired (some likely happening simultaneously." They don't actually provide a shooting sequence, but the locations are:

  • The sixth floor of the Texas School Book Depository

  • The Dal-Tex Building

  • The right front of the grassy knoll area

  • The south knoll (hidden in the triple underpass)


And the books has a "list of men alleged to be in Dallas that day, for whom a strong case for being part of the assassination team can be made." Here is the list:

  • Jean Souetre

  • Herminio Diaz-Garcia

  • Eladio del Valle

  • Charles Nicoletti

  • Colonel Jack Canon

  • David Ferrie

  • Eugene Hale Brading.


This is somewhat different from the podcast series, where Russell admited that his shooting scenario was based on a "highly educated guess." He postulated at least four gunmen who were placed in the TSBD, behind the picket fence, in the Dal-Tex and perhaps the County Records building, and the fatal headshot came from the overpass at the south knoll.


I guess they decided there wasn't a shot from the County Records building.


Here is what they say about David Ferrie: (page 288 in the Kindle edition)

Ferrie’s roommate Raymond Broshears told Dick Russell in 1975 that “David had a twin-engine plane ready” to fly some of JFK’s assassins out of Dallas.

David Ferrie, of course, was NOT in Dallas on that weekend. He was in Houston and Galveston. I have written many blog posts about Raymond Broshears, who was a fabulist of the highest order.


As for Herminio Diaz-Garcia, please check out this blog post.



And Eladio del Valle was not involved as well.


Here is a letter from Bill Barry, a journalist who knew the Cuban community in Miami, about Eladio del Valle.


An examination of the allegations that Eladio del Valle was one of the assassins.


An examination of rumors about Eladio del Valle emanating from the Garrison investigation.



What amazes me about this book is that there is a mountain of evidence against Lee Harvey Oswald, and yet it takes no evidence at all to point the finger at all sorts of people.


Stay tune for more analysis of this book.



Previous Relevant Blog Posts on the Reiner/Russell podcast/book, Who Killed JFK?


Here is the proof that he died of a heart attack.


An outrageous claim without any evidence.


The introduction is cause for concern.


A few thoughts about this book.


There is no evidence tying Willoughby to the assassination.


How on earth could Rob Reiner and his partners believe this ridiculous story?


We take apart the second five episodes of Reiner's podcast on the JFK assassination.


We take apart the first five episodes of Reiner's podcast on the JFK assassination.


Was there a fake defector program at Nags Head, North Carolina?


Flimsy evidence is cited that originated in Hustler Magazine.


Reiner believes the two-Oswald theory.


This blog post also covers the concluding episode of Reiner's podcast.


Conspiracy theorists have no regard for truth.





Post: Blog2_Post

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

©2020 by On The Trail of Delusion. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page